Social Media Dismissal: Court declines to lay down guidance

2015-08-13 Philip posted:

Was it unfair to dismiss an employee for comments made on Facebook which he claimed were untrue?

No, held the Employment Appeal Tribunal in the case of British Waterways Board v Smith in a cautionary tale for all social media users.

Mr Smith had made derogatory comments on Facebook about his managers and work, and a claim that two years earlier he had been drinking whilst on standby. During standby periods, workers were not permitted to consume alcohol. Mr Smith then denied that he had in fact been drinking, and claimed that the comments were banter, he was summarily dismissed on the grounds of gross misconduct as his comments had undermined the confidence his employer or the public could have in him.

Despite finding that the employer had carried out a reasonable investigation and had a genuine belief based on reasonable grounds that the Claimant had made the comments, the employment tribunal found that the dismissal was unfair as the employer had failed to consider the Claimant's mitigation, including the point that some claims made on Facebook are exaggerated or not true.

The EAT overturned that decision and held that the dismissal was fair. Having found that the procedure was fair, the employment tribunal must have concluded that the Claimant's mitigation was taken into account (which the EAT thought it had), and the employment tribunal had substituted their view for that of the employer.

Share this post

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Share this post

Twitter

And we're out with update 5 - read on for guidance on updates to the furlough scheme and how holiday/annual leave htwitter.com/i/web/status/1…mg

Twitter

There have been some developments on the job retention scheme (the furlough scheme), which has now been extended totwitter.com/i/web/status/1…YB

Twitter

With changes happening on a daily basis due to #COVID19 I've had lots of questions from both employers and employeetwitter.com/i/web/status/1…Nm

Testimonial

I was very pleased with the speed of dealing with my business. From the appointment - which was also made quickly- to the advice given and speed of resolving my issues.

Lynn Harrison

Testimonial

This is the first occasion that I have needed the services of an Employment Solicitor and viewed the prospect with a certain amount of trepidation. I need not have worried. Philip McCabe took me through the process with sympathy and understanding. He gave me sound advice and when needed acted promptly and effectively bringing matters to a successful conclusion. I would recommend his services to anyone.

WG